Honest Review of Quince Clothing: Is It Worth The Hype?

I’ve ordered a lot from Quince – their dresses, cashmere, shoes, swimsuits, leather bags, and baby items. Quince is an online retailer that sells insanely high-quality clothing, shoes, and accessories at insanely low prices. Their entire mission is to create quality products (sustainably) and cut out the middleman cost by selling directly to consumers using a factory-direct model. So instead of buying their clothes from a factory, marking them up like other retailers, and then selling them at the prices you’re used to seeing, they sell the same goods without the usual expenses of a regular supply chain (like sourcing agents, warehousing, wholesaling, distribution, and storefront retail). Read more about how that works here on their About page.

I’m obsessed with Quince because they have fabrics like Mongolian cashmere, Italian leather, and organic cotton at prices I can’t find anywhere else. I’ve ordered a handful of things from Quince over the last 6 months, and I’m reviewing each piece below. Trust me, you’re going to want to place an order.

Honest Review of Quince Clothing: Is It Worth The Hype?

Everything I’ve Bought from Quince

As I mentioned, Quince carries more than just clothing. They have shoes, bags, jewelry, baby & kids stuff, and men’s items. I’ve tested their jeans, activewear, accessories, and even baby essentials for myself, and here’s a breakdown of my experience.

Jeans

I bought the Stretch High Rise Kick Flare Jeans from Quince, and the fit is unbelievable. They actually remind me a lot of my Madewell jeans, both in terms of fit and quality, and those typically cost $100+. If you’re looking for classic, well-made jeans at an affordable price, these are a must-buy. The fit has a nice stretch, and fits well on the booty. I’m 5’1″, so I bought the 26″ inseam. I’m dying to try a few of their other styles like the Bella Stretch Patch Pocket Wide Leg Jeans.

The only note I have is that they do stretch out after one to two wears, so just plan to wash/dry them after every few wears. I am truly obsessed with these.

Dresses

The quality of the Quince 100% Organic Cotton Poplin Smocked Midi Dress I bought is very similar to the Ellie Hill House Home dress that’s so popular (you can read my Hill House dress review here), but the price is much more affordable. The fit is great on top, but I did notice some pulling on the back near the glutes. I returned one for a larger size to see if that helps. Overall, it’s flattering and well-made. I do wish it had pockets, but for the price, I won’t complain.

I also ordered this Poplin Short Sleeve Ruffle Shirt Dress. It’s a simple shirt dress shape, but the ruffle details give it a feminine flair. I found it a bit too large on my petite frame, but I think it would work well on someone taller!

The third dress I tried was the Vintage Wash Tencel Button Front Dress. The fit is shockingly flattering, and the hook and eye closure is a nice touch for such an affordable dress!

Lastly, I’m not sure if it counts as a dress, but since it’s one piece and you’d wear it similarly, I’m including it here: the 100% Organic Cotton Gauze Smocked Wide Leg Jumpsuit. I was blown away by how comfortable and flattering it is! The straps are adjustable (I didn’t realize this the first time I tried it on), and the smocking is well-made. This would be a great breastfeeding-friendly option.

Blouses/Tops

Now that it’s a little warmer, I really want to snag a few Quince tops. I’m eyeing the Cotton Gauze Peasant Blouse to wear with jean shorts (here’s my roundup of the best jean shorts). This European Linen Cropped Tank is a great basic top to style with jeans and shorts, too.

Shorts/Skirts

I ordered the 100% European Linen Shorts this spring and was blown away by the fit and quality. Linen can be so finicky – these shorts are not see-through, the length is great, and the fit is flattering. Definite winners! They run true to size.

Another winner: This 100% Organic Cotton Poplin Tiered Maxi Skirt. It’s lined, has pockets, and a wide waistband, and comes in a ton of colors. I’ve become quite the skirt gal over the past year, and I can’t wait to wear this one all spring and summer.

Purses/Bags

I purchased this Italian Leather Convertible Crescent Handwoven Shoulder Bag from Quince, and it totally exceeded my expectations. The leather feels so nice, the zippers are sturdy, and the structure holds up well over time. If you’re looking for an affordable luxury handbag, this is a solid choice. I want to try this Italian Leather Handwoven Flap Crossbody for a summer purse. They also carry a ton of luggage options, and I’m thinking I’ll need to test out this Italian Leather Triple Compartment Weekender – you know, for research purposes.

Quince Cashmere Sweaters

The Quince cashmere crewneck and v-neck sweaters are some of the best pieces in my wardrobe. They also make short-sleeved sweaters, which are perfect for the spring. They’re soft, lightweight, and made from Mongolian cashmere–and great for layering. I own them in an XS, and they have a comfortably loose fit. Despite regular wear (and I do wear them often), they haven’t pilled or gotten holes in them, which is impressive given the price tag. If you’re looking for luxe knits, Quince cashmere is a no-brainer. I can’t believe I was spending well over $100 before on cashmere sweaters that look (and feel!) identical to Quince.

Shoes

In my experience, Quince shoes run larger and wider than other brands. I usually wear a 6.5 or 7, and the 7 was too big in both pairs I tried (Water Repellent Suede Clog Mule and Italian Leather Horsebit Loafer). If you’re in between sizes, I’d suggest sizing down. The Italian leather on the loafers feels premium, and the suede clogs are very well made and don’t look like they’re a budget option. (They’re significantly nicer than the Amazon version of the Birkenstock dupes I purchased and subsequently returned.)

Activewear (Workout Tops and Shorts)

The workout tops (specifically the Essential Run Tee) and shorts (I tried the Micro Ripstop Mid-Rise Short) are made of soft, durable fabric with great color options. However, I found the tops to be longer than I preferred, and the shorts ran bigger than expected. I’d recommend sizing down or ordering your usual size if you prefer a looser fit. I haven’t tried the Quince leggings and sports bras yet, and those are next on my list – I love the bright blue color option they have right now!

Swimsuits

In general, the Quince swimsuits are good quality with classic designs. However, neither of the two I ordered has as much compression as I’d like. I did keep the Italian Plunge Ribbed One-Piece Swimsuit since it was a little sexy but not too revealing (the best kind of swimsuit, in my opinion), but I returned the Italian Cami Ribbed One-Piece Swimsuit since it’s not nearly as good as my go-to La Blanca Island Goddess swimsuit. That one is also budget-friendly and much more flattering.

Baby Pajamas

The Bamboo Long Sleeve Pant Pajamas Set is super soft and adorable! However, they ran small. My baby is 12 months old and on the smaller side, yet the 12-18 month pajamas didn’t fit. I’d recommend sizing up.

Cashmere Gloves

Absolutely gorgeous. These Mongolian Cashmere Gloves are as nice as a pair I own that costs nearly $100.

Baby Sleep Sack

The Bamboo Sleep Bag is my absolute favorite sleep sack for the boys. It’s softer and cozier than others I’ve tried, and it holds up better in the wash than Kyte sleep sacks. Highly recommend!

Crib Sheets

I didn’t love the European Linen Fitted Crib Sheets since they felt a little rough. I ended up returning them and sticking with my go-to Solly sheets.

FAQs

Quince Quality

The quality is what sold me on Quince. I don’t love shopping at places like Old Navy or Target super often since the quality doesn’t hold up as well as the pricier brands I own, but Quince blows me away every time, and the prices are so much better than what I usually pay for similar items.

Quince Sizing

I have to say, Quince’s sizing isn’t quite as consistent, and it varies by category. For shoes, I’d recommend sizing down if you’re between sizes. For baby clothing, sizing up might be a good idea. Jeans, sweaters, and dresses tend to fit true-to-size, but if you’re curvier on the bottom, you may want to size up.

Return Policy

Quince has a hassle-free return policy, which makes trying out different sizes and styles easy. They offer free returns within 365 days, which is a huge plus.

Final Thoughts

Overall, Quince delivers on its promise of affordable luxury. The cashmere sweaters, jeans, and baby sleep sacks are standout purchases, while some pieces (like crib sheets and swimwear) may not work for everyone. If you’re looking for high-quality wardrobe staples without the premium price tag, Quince is definitely worth a try.

Shop The Post