Quince Clothing Review: Honest Take After 2+ Years of Buying

I’ve ordered a lot from Quince over the past few years. Dresses, cashmere, shoes, swimsuits, leather bags, baby items, and activewear. At this point, I feel very qualified to give an honest Quince clothing review.

Quince is an online retailer that sells high-quality clothing, shoes, and accessories at surprisingly low prices. Their mission is to create quality products sustainably and cut out the middleman by selling directly to consumers using a factory-direct model.

I’ve tried a lot. Some pieces are incredible. Some are just okay. A few were definite misses.

Quick Answer: Is Quince Worth It?

After 2+ years of buying, I’ll be honest: I have mixed feelings.

Quince is not a slow-fashion brand built to last a decade. But it is solidly better than Target or Amazon, and the value in certain categories is genuinely hard to beat. The catch? Quality is hit or miss depending on the category.

The sweet spot: If your budget or lifestyle does not allow for $200 jeans or $250 sweaters from brands like Frank & Eileen (hello, young kids!), Quince is a great option. If you like owning something for a few years and then replacing it, rather than investing in forever pieces, you will likely love it.

What Is Quince Clothing?

Quince (also known as One Quince; @onequince is their Instagram handle) is a direct-to-consumer brand selling elevated basics at accessible prices. Think Mongolian cashmere sweaters, Italian leather bags, organic cotton dresses, and Lululemon-comparable leggings at a fraction of the expected price.

Is Quince legit? Yes, absolutely. It’s a real brand with genuinely good quality in several categories. Just go in knowing it is not luxury-tier, and some categories are better than others.

Quince Clothing Review: Everything I’ve Tried

Everything below is organized by category with a YES, MAYBE, or NO verdict and my size listed for each item.

Denim

Stretch High Rise Kick Flare Jeans – YES
Size 2, 26″ inseam

The fit is unbelievable. These remind me of my Madewell jeans in fit and quality, and those cost $100+. Nice stretch, great in the booty. One note: they stretch out after one to two wears, so plan to wash and dry them every few wears. The wash and fit range is not quite as varied as designer denim, but for the price, these are outstanding. I am truly obsessed.

Bella Stretch Relaxed Straight Jeans – YES
Size 2, 26″ inseam

A bestseller for good reason, and I wear these all the time. Like the kick flares, they do stretch out, so you may want to consider sizing down. A great everyday wide-leg option at a very hard-to-argue-with price.

Cashmere

A quick note on Quince cashmere overall: impressive for the price, but compared to higher-end cashmere I own, it feels slightly lighter and less substantial. Think excellent everyday cashmere, not a forever investment piece.

Crewneck & V-Neck Cashmere Sweaters – YES
Size Small

Soft, lightweight, and layers beautifully. I used to spend $100+ on cashmere that looks and feels nearly identical. None of mine have pilled or gotten holes with regular wear. A great layering piece year-round. You can find my other favorite cashmere sweaters here.

Mongolian Cashmere Dolman Sleeve Henley Sweater – YES
Size Small

A 10/10. True to size, not itchy at all. The lightweight feel works well from spring through early fall. One of those sweaters that looks elevated but still feels easy.

Mongolian Cashmere Cropped Crew Cardigan – YES
Size Small

I had been searching for a cardigan like this for a while. Buttons without gapping. It works layered over a tee, worn over the shoulders, or even with dresses. The color works year-round, which I love.

Mongolian Cashmere Gloves – YES

These are as nice as a pair I own that costs nearly $100.

Dresses

Vintage Wash Tencel Button Front Dress – YES

Shockingly flattering for the price. Easy to layer with a denim jacket or light cardigan in spring, or wear on its own as it warms up into summer. Pairs great with loafers or sneakers.

100% Organic Cotton Poplin Smocked Midi Dress – MAYBE

The quality of this dress is very similar to the Ellie Hill House Home dress, but more affordable. (You can read my Hill House dress review here.) Fit is great on top, but I noticed pulling near the hips and had to exchange for a larger size. No pockets, which is a miss. Read the size notes carefully before ordering.

Tops

Sleeveless Polo – Give me anything polo and I love it, this was no exception. It has a bit of stretch, so it drapes nicely and does not feel fussy. There is no gapping, and it lays really well. It is a definite keeper.

Lightweight Blue Sweater – I snagged this sweater because I wanted something that could be worn on its own or layered. It’s a yes for me because it gives you a longer shelf life into spring and summer.

Blue Button-Down – This shirt has a slightly lived-in look, which makes it feel less precious than a crisp white shirt. I wear it with jeans, layered over a tank, or even as a pool cover-up. I love pieces that are so versatile, and this one definitely meets the mark.

Stretch Crepe Double-Breasted Blazer – This is a solid classic and depending on your body type it might be great for you. For me, it runs slightly long; I wish it came in petite sizing! (Remember I’m only 5’1″, so someone taller might really find this as a win.)

Pants

100% European Linen Pants – The lightweight linen fabric makes them work perfectly in the transitional season months. Pairs great with a t-shirt and sandals for spring, or a chunky sweater moving into colder months.

Stretch Crepe Pleated Shorts – I tried these in a size four and they fit well everywhere except the waist, which was just slightly too tight. If you have a smaller waist, you may love them. Otherwise, sizing up might help, though it could make them larger elsewhere.

Trouser Pants – I experienced the same sizing issue with the pants as I did the shorts. Slightly snug in the waist and a little tight through the hips. I would recommend sizing up one size.

Everyday Fleece Joggers – I wanted these to work, but they were also very long on me and heavier than I expected. They feel more fall and winter weight than spring.

Bags

Italian Leather Convertible Crescent Handwoven Shoulder Bag – This bag completely exceeded my expectations! The leather feels high-end, the zippers are sturdy, and the structure holds up well. If you’re looking for an affordable luxury handbag, this is a solid choice.

Activewear

Quince Leggings – The leggings have strong compression but still feel buttery soft, and I was very impressed with the quality. They feel more supportive than some of my Amazon pairs. I stopped buying Lululemon because the quality no longer felt worth the price to me, and these feel like a strong alternative.

Quince Sports Bra – I felt like this offered great support without feeling restrictive. I bought two more after getting this one!

Essential Run Tee – The color options and fabric on this very soft and durable. However, it was much longer than I prefer. May work if you’re average height or taller!

Micro Ripstop Mid-Rise Short – These shorts ran much bigger than expected, I’d recommend sizing down or ordering your normal size if you prefer a looser fit.

Shoes

Quince shoes overall run larger and wider than other brands. I usually wear a 6.5 or 7, and the 7 was too big in both pairs I tried.

Water Repellent Suede Clog Mule and Italian Leather Horsebit Loafer – If you’re in between sizes, I’d suggest sizing down. The Italian leather on the loafers feels premium, and the suede clogs are very well made and don’t look like they’re a budget option. (They’re significantly nicer than the Amazon version of the Birkenstock dupes I purchased and subsequently returned.)

Swimwear

Italian Plunge Ribbed One-Piece Swimsuit – This was flattering enough for me to keep. It is a little sexy but not too revealing. (The best kind of swimsuit, in my opinion.)

Red Swimsuit – I love the color and the wide waistband under the bust on this swimsuit. The straps may work better for someone taller…again, short person problems.

Italian Cami Ribbed One-Piece Swimsuit – This wasn’t terrible, but I did return it since it’s not nearly as good as my go-to La Blanca Island Goddess swimsuit. That one is also budget-friendly and much more flattering. (Here are more mom-friendly swimsuits I love.)

Green Swimsuit – This simply did not work for me. The cups were too small, and the body lacked shaping, which made it less flattering.

Black Swimsuit – This suit ran extremely small compared to the others. I could barely get it on in the same size! Pass for me.

Overall, the compression in Quince swimwear is lighter than I prefer.

Baby Essentials

Bamboo Sleep Bag – This is my absolute favorite sleep sack for the boys. It’s softer and cozier than others I’ve tried, and it holds up better in the wash than Kyte sleep sacks. Highly recommend!

The Bamboo Long Sleeve Pant Pajamas Set – This set is so soft and adorable! I wanted to love it, however, they run small, and honestly, showed wear pretty quickly. I bought them when my baby was 12 months old, yet the 12-18 month pajamas didn’t fit. I’d recommend sizing up or skipping altogether. (These are my favorite brands for toddler boy clothes!)

European Linen Fitted Crib Sheets – These were a ‘no’ for me since they felt a little rough. I ended up returning them and sticking with my go-to Solly sheets.

FAQs

Is Quince Good Quality?

The quality is what sold me on Quince. I don’t love shopping at places like Old Navy or Target super often since the quality doesn’t hold up as well as the pricier brands I own. Quince cashmere, denim, leather bags, and baby sleep essentials consistently impress me. Some tailored pieces and swimwear can be inconsistent, but overall the quality is strong for the price.

Does Quince Run True To Size?

Sizing varies by category. Cashmere, jeans and dresses run true to size for me. Trouser pants and shorts run small in the waist. Shoes run slightly large and activewear was inconsistent depending on the piece. For baby clothing, sizing up might be a good idea.

Return Policy

Quince has a hassle-free return policy, which makes trying out different sizes and styles easy. They offer free returns within 365 days, which is a huge plus.

Is Quince Worth It?

For wardrobe staples like cashmere, denim, and leather goods, absolutely. Just pay attention to fit notes in tailored pieces and swimwear.

Final Thoughts

Overall, Quince delivers on its promise of affordable luxury. The cashmere sweaters, jeans, leather bags, and baby sleep sacks are standout purchases. Some categories require more attention to fit, but when you choose wisely, the value is hard to beat.

Shop The Post