brand icon Nov72025

The Cutest Fair Isle Christmas Sweaters to Buy This Year

post featured image no-lazy post featured image
The following content may contain affiliate links. When you click and shop the links, we receive a commission.

Updated November 2026

I’ve always loved Fair Isle sweaters. They’re classic and festive, without feeling like a full-on ugly Christmas sweater, and I love the fact that you can wear them all winter, long after the holidays. This year, I rounded up Fair Isle sweaters at every price point, from a LOFT sale find to a Jenni Kayne crewneck to keep for years.

Whether you’re looking for a festive, classic holiday sweater or you need something for a tacky Christmas sweater party (but don’t want to spend money on something truly tacky, I’ve got you covered with the finds in this post. But if you want an ugly Christmas sweater, I’ve got that covered too.

If you need more holiday-inspired shopping picks, check out these posts:

The 10 Cutest Fair Isle Christmas Sweaters I’ve Found

Tuckernuck Fair Isle cashmere cardigan in dusty blue with a cream and navy patterned yoke, worn with straight-leg jeans

1. Tuckernuck Slate Fair Isle Cashmere Moritz Cardigan

Tuckernuck carries Fair Isle in every style, from cropped sweaters to long, cozy cardigans, and the Tuckernuck Fair Isle Cashmere Cardigan in dusty blue is my favorite from them this year.

Pink fair isle crewneck sweater with a multicolor knit pattern, styled with dark wash jeans

2. Boden Edie Fair Isle Sweater

If you want a Fair Isle that works well into February and March, the Boden Fair Isle Sweater in Pink is it. (And it’s in my cart.)

LOFT Fair Isle ribbed sweater in light blue with a navy and white patterned yoke, worn with a tan belt and jeans

3. LOFT Fair Isle Ribbed Sweater

LOFT sells some of the best Fair Isle sweaters every year, and my top pick last year sold out fast. The sale price on the LOFT Fair Isle Ribbed Sweater is a steal, so I wouldn’t wait.

J.Crew Fair Isle mockneck sweater in cream with a light blue and charcoal yoke and matching patterned cuffs

4. J.Crew Fair Isle Mockneck Sweater

I love the cream and light blue on the J.Crew Fair Isle Mockneck Sweater because it’s pretty for winter and not overly Christmas. This one also comes in a navy option I like.

Amazon Fair Isle cable knit sweater in cream with a black and gray patterned yoke, worn with white trousers

5. Amazon Fair Isle Cable Knit Sweater

If you like the look of the one above, but not the price, try this. Cable knit and Fair Isle in one sweater seems like a match made in heaven, and the Amazon Fair Isle Cable Knit Sweater has both.

Quince Australian merino wool Fair Isle crewneck cardigan in cream with a black floral yoke and gold buttons

6. Quince Australian Merino Wool Fair Isle Crewneck Cardigan

Every year, Quince has a Fair Isle I want to buy because their designs aren’t over the top and the prices are great. This year it’s the Quince Fair Isle Crewneck Cardigan.

Marea Louise Fair Isle cardigan in chocolate brown with a cream and berry patterned yoke and tortoiseshell buttons

7. Marea Louise Fair Isle Cardigan

The Louise Fair Isle Cardigan in Chocolate is a splurge from a brand I love. The brown is unique, and it’s a style I’d keep wearing for years, well past the holidays.

Jenni Kayne Sterling Fair Isle crewneck sweater in oatmeal with brown and green bands, worn with olive trousers

8. Jenni Kayne Sterling Crewneck

Jenni Kayne has a cult following for the quality of its sweaters, and I like the slightly oversized fit of the Jenni Kayne Sterling Crewneck. It’s an investment, but if you want a Fair Isle to keep for a lifetime, this could be it.

Marea shawl cardigan in navy with a light blue intarsia flower pattern and white dot details

9. Marea Shawl Cardigan

Technically, the Marea Shawl Cardigan in Intarsia Flower is an intarsia pattern, not a true Fair Isle, but it’s in the same vein. I like the oversized fit, and the navy works for nearly any time of year.

Kiel James Patrick Saranac Fern Fair Isle cardigan in green with mustard, red, and blue bands, worn with jeans

10. Kiel James Patrick Saranac Fern Fair Isle Cardigan

KJP sells more Fair Isle designs than any other brand I’ve found, with Halloween and Thanksgiving prints on top of the Christmas ones, plus season-neutral options like the Fern Fair Isle Cardigan. I especially love the pops of mustard.

What is a Fair Isle Sweater?

Fair Isle sweaters today come from a traditional knitting technique named after Fair Isle, one of the Shetland Islands. They became super popular when the Prince of Wales, Edward VIII, wore them around the 1920s. Since then, the term Fair Isle has become pretty generic and typically refers to any multicolored, geometric knitwear. And it’s still common to see the royals wearing them in the winter. Most of the time, when you see a festive, Christmas-y feeling sweater, it’s a Fair Isle-inspired sweater.

What are the Different Types of Fair Isle Sweaters?

Fair Isle sweaters come in many patterns and colors, but I’m not sure if there are truly different types of Fair Isle knitwear with distinct names (please comment and share if you know!) Most traditional Fair Isle patterns have been passed down through generations, so a specific knitter may have a style that was easy to identify in some communities, which is pretty cool. Some common patterns that are popular right now are eight-pointed stars, Nordic snowflakes, diamonds, and Christmas-themed patterns (e.g., reindeer, trucks, stockings, etc.).

Can You Wear Fair Isle After Christmas?

Yes, and I wear mine well past the holidays. A Fair Isle in cream, navy, brown, or oatmeal is a winter sweater, so it still looks good with jeans after the tree comes down. I pack away anything with reindeer, Christmas trees, or red and green with the rest of the decorations.

If you want a new one that lasts past the holidays, the pink Boden Edie works into February and March, and the J.Crew mockneck in cream and light blue isn’t overly Christmas. Kiel James Patrick also makes Fair Isle designs for nearly every season and holiday, so browse Kiel James Patrick Women’s Apparel for options beyond December.

Why Is Fair Isle So Expensive?

Traditional Fair Isle is hand-knit stranded colorwork in Shetland wool, which takes a lot of skill and time, so the authentic ones cost real money. Most of the retail picks in this post are machine-knit and Fair Isle-inspired, which is how they come in at a fraction of the price.

Are Fair Isle Sweaters Still in Style?

Yes, Fair Isle sweaters are still in style in 2026. The classic colorways are winter staples I wear year after year, and only the holiday prints are seasonal. If you’re buying your first one, I’d start with a neutral and save the reindeer for a second sweater.

Where Can I Buy an Authentic Fair Isle Sweater?

If you’re looking for a truly authentic Fair Isle sweater, you can still buy them directly from the makers, but most retailers make similar styles around the holidays. For an authentic one, I’d start with The Croft House or Exclusively Fair Isle, or browse the authentic Fair Isle sweaters on Etsy.

I love the unique color of the Eribe Fairisle Westray Sweater in Portree, which is 100% Shetland wool. It works for all of fall and into the holiday season.

How to style Fair Isle Sweaters for the Winter Season

My favorite way to wear my Fair Isle sweaters is with denim. Depending on the length of the sweater, I’ll tuck it into my jeans or do a small front tuck. I wear them casually, but I’ve seen Kate Middleton pair hers with a blazer, which looked so cute.

A Fair Isle with dark denim is one of the looks in my guide to what to wear on Christmas Eve, and it’s a great casual option for a holiday work party too.

The two sweaters below are both from Petite Studio. They no longer have these exact styles, but they do have a merino wool Fair Isle sweater in stock right now.

The Bottom Line

If you’re buying one Fair Isle sweater this year, go with a classic colorway like cream, navy, or brown so you can keep wearing it with jeans through February. My first pick is the LOFT Fair Isle Ribbed Sweater, since LOFT’s Fair Isle sweaters sell out fast. If you want one to keep for years, the Jenni Kayne Sterling Crewneck is worth the investment.

Alright, I’ll wrap this up and go decide whether that pink Boden Edie is finally leaving my cart and coming to my house.

Shop the Post

terilyn signatureterilyn signature

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    One response to “The Cutest Fair Isle Christmas Sweaters to Buy This Year”

    1. I ordered that hyacinth house sweater a few days ago! Hah. And LOVE my pistola Lennon jeans I was influenced to buy!

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *