Where to Stay in St. John USVI

post featured image
The following content may contain affiliate links. When you click and shop the links, we receive a commission.

Get details on where to stay in St. John USVI and pros and cons of different spots on the island, plus an amazing villa that I found on VRBO.

I’ve been a bit MIA but I just haven’t really felt like being on a computer since I’ve been home from vacation! Don’t you worry, I’ve been keeping busy with really important stuff like binge watching season 2 of Orange is the New Black. 🙂 I was  pretty productive over the weekend though: yesterday I mowed the grass at 8 AM (luckily all my neighbors are early risers), trimmed the hedges, cleaned the driveway and sideway with the blower, cleaned both bathrooms, and vacuumed and mopped, including UNDER THE OVEN AND COUCH–PLEASE BE PROUD. 🙂   And tonight, Maizey and I are holed up in the house, being all cozy, while it thunders and pours outside. Well, I’m being cozy. Maizey is hiding underneath the kitchen table. Poor thing!

IMG 6058

Alright, here are finally some pictures from my trip to St. John!  I got a number of questions about my trip, so I’ll share the pictures in a series covering the most common questions in each. This will help answer questions and prevent picture overload for those of you that just want to see pictures! Today’s topic: how to get to St. John and where to stay in St. John. 🙂

Getting there:

To get to St. John, you fly into St. Thomas and that is the worst part. 🙂 But really, it’s not too bad getting over to St. John. Rent your car at the STT airport and take the car barge over; it’s cheaper that way than taking a taxi to the human ferry and renting a car on St. John.  Be sure to book with Budget since they allow you to take the car off the St. Thomas island. Get right off the plane and go directly to the car rental since that line can get long quickly. Send your travel buddy to fetch a beer for you while you wait since there are zero container laws in the U.S. Virgin Islands.

IMG 5601

Rent a jeep.

Seriously, just do. The roads are very very very steep and if you explore at all, the roads are rough. Our tires squealed every day driving; I’ve never been on roads like this. Sometimes it was so steep I couldn’t see the road over the dashboard. Lucky for me, John handled the driving.

IMG 5672

Be sure to drive on the left hand side of the road!!! 🙂 This was kinda weird at first, but we adapted after a few days. I never even drove while we were there, but when I came home and I accidentally turned into the wrong lane one day. ha!

IMG 5602

Put on your happy face once you make it to the Red Hook Ferry, about 30 minutes from the airport (just follow route 30 and the starfish signs leading you east), and you’re on your way to St. John. Be sure to have cash. The car barge only takes cash. And book round trip if you want – it’ll save you $10. And get a beer for the ride over if you want. 🙂

IMG 5608

When we got to St. John, an employee from the villa rental company met us at the ferry dock and took us to our place. I found the house through VRBO and I almost always prefer to use VRBO or AirBNB for booking accommodations when traveling. I like to have access to a kitchen since eating out can be expensive and, depending on the city, it can difficult to find food that I can/want to eat. For St. John, I found a great house for a very affordable price–traveling in the off-season helped a ton with the price. I could go on for days about why renting a house/condo trumps a hotel but I’m sure most of you are familiar with VRBO so I won’t go into it. (But, if you want more details, let me know!)

This is where we stayed – the Christy Ann Villa.

SAM 0587

The house was near Rendezvous Point and overlooked Fish Bay.

IMG 5613

It had very high ceilings…

IMG 5674

and amazing views out every window. The kitchen was fully stocked with plates, pots, pans, tupperware, everything you could need, which was great.

IMG 5911

It also had a huge deck with a hot tub.

IMG 5916

We started and finished every day relaxing on the deck.


SAM 0567

I was so sad to leave.

SAM 0652

There is only one resort on the island, the Westin. We went there one day to use their gym and seriously, everyone staying there looked really grumpy. I looked at it when planning the trip, but the rooms looked tiny and crazy overpriced. And there is so much to see the island and better beaches than Westin’s private beach that I don’t think it’s really worth staying at the resort. And the island is so small that you aren’t really getting an extra convenient location by staying at the Westin. You can get more for your money in a privately owned house.

When you’re looking at areas to stay in, look for these: Chocolate Hole, Rendezvous Point, Fish Bay, Hart Bay…basically anything along the southwest side of the island. These are where most of the privately owned houses are. I wouldn’t stay in Great Cruz Bay — crowded and probably loud. And I wouldn’t stay in Coral Bay (the other side of the island, although just 30 minutes away) unless you really wanted to be remote.

Where to Stay in St. JOhnsource

The best beaches are on the northwest side of the island between Cruz Bay and Maho Bay, but there aren’t many houses to stay in on the northwest side…it’s undeveloped over by the beaches which keeps it pristine and beautiful. Don’t let the map deceive you; we stayed near Fish Bay and we were at Hawksnest Bay in about 10 minutes. It’s really a tiny island…I think I read it’s only 9×4 miles!

Next up: what to do in St. John, the best beaches, and where to eat!

Have you been to the Caribbean? This was my first time! If you’ve been, where? 

terilyn signatureterilyn signature

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    19 responses to “Where to Stay in St. John USVI”

    1. I rented a villa in Chocolate Hole-St. John was the best vaca of my life!

    2. That is a gorgeous house! I’ve never done rent-by-owner but would like to try it. I went to St. John last year for my honeymoon, and honeymoon beach was my favorite. Not just because of the name 😉 Ha.

    3. Loved this post! I’ve been to St. John before and am heading back in 1 1/2 weeks and this is making me excited!! Can’t wait to read more!

    4. Beautiful!! I have not looked into AirBNB or VRBO, but will certainly do so after reading this post. Being vegetarian and trying to stick to whole grains, no sugar, etc., I like to have cooking facilities also–plus, it’s fun to try local ingredients in the markets.

      My first trip to the Caribbean was in 1981 (yes, this dates me!) when my husband was doing his grad school archaeological fieldwork at Copan Ruinas, Honduras. That is not on the Caribbean, but we took a bus (pigs, chickens, etc.) up to Tela on the Caribbean. The culture along the Caribbean is very different from the interior of Honduras. The population includes the Garifuna people, who are of African, Arawak, and Carib descent. We ate coconut bread that we bought on the beach and caracol (conch) every night in various hotels and restaurants. In the early 1900s, Tela became an HQ for United Fruit Company and there was actually a railroad built that could carry pineapples and bananas right out to the beach for shipping.

      It was an adventure. We were very young and poor, poor, POOR graduate students, but had a blast. We later took our older son with us, sometimes for weeks or months at a time. When he was 5, we went to another Honduran Caribbean city (Puerto Cortez) and saw a rabid dog on the beach–vivid memories for our little kid. Honduras was the poorest country in the western hemisphere at the time, and now it also has the highest murder rate in the world. Sad.

      Many scuba divers and snorklers go to the Bay Islands (especially Roatan) off the coast of Honduras because of the incredible coral reefs.

    5. That house, and that view, are gorgeous! I love VRBO and check out the options every time we go on vacation, anywhere. We go to Playa del Carmen, MX every year, where we technically wade in the Caribbean Sea every day, but it’s still Mexico and therefore I don’t think of it as “the Caribbean”. This year we also went to Jamaica and absolutely loved it. Can’t wait to start working our way into even more Caribbean Caribbean destinations! 🙂

    6. I have heard a lot about St. John and love to visit too. These details mentioned by you are really helpful for me to plan my trip to St. John. I just want to know little more about Villa Provisioning St. John. Which is best vacation homes or luxury resorts and the price differences?

    7. There is another resort on the Island called Caneel Bay which was the first resort and owned by the Rockefellers! We are heading down again next mo. Our friends retired down there and started a charter co doing snorkeling tours! Talk about living the dream?!!!

    8. Hello there! I would like to hear more about the caneel resort.. Any helpfull eexperiencia Thanks for your time!

    9. Hi! Loved your post about St. John and Christy Ann. I am in talks with the owner of renting this property for our upcoming visit. It really seems like a goid fit for my famy but wold like to know how clean it is and if you ran into any issues with bugs or Mosquitos. I have two younger children traveling with me. The owner seems really nice and trustworthy. Is appreciate your input as far as pros and cons of staying at the condo. Thanks!


      • Hi Diana – I would definitely recommend staying at the Christy Ann. There were some bugs, but nothing major. I don’t recall a mosquito problem and I’m typically the person they are attracted to. The owner (Peter, I believe?) was wonderful to work with – very kind and helpful. The only con was that it’s a little bit of a drive from the town, so you can’t walk to restaurants and there are some steep and windy roads driving into and out of town, but I actually liked being away from the action since I like it to be quiet at night. Let me know if you have other questions. Enjoy your trip!

    10. Hi Terilyn,
      Thank you for your blog about St John! What year did you go? It says June 9 but there isnt a year 🙂

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.