brand icon Jun2

Naturepedic Mattress Review (NOT-sponsored)

post featured image no-lazy post featured image
The following content may contain affiliate links. When you click and shop the links, we receive a commission.

Use this Naturepedic link and code TERI15 for 15% off and FREE SHIPPING off your mattress

When Tommy and I got married, the first thing we purchased was a new mattress. There was no way we were going to share a queen-sized bed since we are both mattress hogs. But, given our schedules and time crunch, we didn’t have time to shop around and try mattresses out in person. So, I did some research and purchased a mattress in a box that was mailed to our front door.

For the first few months, we thought it was okay. I mean, it smelled awful (this is called off-gassing), but it wasn’t too hard to unbox (once we got it upstairs, which was a nightmare since it was so heavy), and it was fine to sleep on…at first. Then, just a few months later, we absolutely hated it.

In short, we were both desperate for a new mattress.

I researched a few but was wary of buying online again. I asked my friends what mattresses they had, but all of them sounded similar to the one we had before with memory foam. But then, when a friend told me about Naturepedic, I felt like I’d found my perfect match and couldn’t wait to try it.

Fast forward to 2024: we’ve purchased FOUR Naturepedic mattresses– one for our primary bedroom, our guest room, one for our son’s room, and one for our vacation home. We have the EOS Classic Mattress in the adult rooms and the Serenade Organic Hybrid Mattress in our son’s room. (We briefly tried the pillow top but didn’t like it and ended up exchanging it since we prefer a very firm mattress. More on that below.)

I also have a video at the bottom of the post showing you how to assemble it, so be sure to check back once you get yours.

NOT-SPONSORED Naturepedic Mattress Review

The TLDR: we LOVE our Naturepedic mattresses. The best non-toxic organic mattress is Naturepedic because of its materials, craftsmanship, and customer service– and the fact that it’s made in the United States.

I share more details below, but if you’re on the fence, do yourself a favor and order one. You spend 6-8 hours of your life on a mattress every single day of your life. You should love it. And it shouldn’t be full of crap since you spend so much time on it. (Most mattresses are made with pretty toxic materials.) More on all of that below.

So, what makes Naturepedic mattresses different?

They are one of the safest mattresses you can buy. When I learned what is in conventional mattresses, I couldn’t believe it; I didn’t know so many chemicals were allowed, especially when you think about how much time you spend on your mattress. I wish I’d switched to a safer mattress a long time ago. (Safe skincare is important to me, so I’m not sure why I never thought about my mattress.)

They never use materials like flame retardants, formaldehyde, or polyurethane foam and eliminate any chemicals that could negatively impact your health. There are many opinions about what chemicals are dangerous, their dosage, if they really matter, etc. So Naturepedic just eliminates them in the first place to avoid any potential harm.

As a mom, I’m very grateful for the peace of mind that comes with a Naturepedic mattress. As infants, Thomas and Charles spent a lot of time in our bed (we loved our mornings as a family!), so it’s important our mattress is safe for them, as well. I wished I’d known about the Naturepedic baby mattress when I purchased Thomas’ crib mattress years ago, but I do feel pretty good about the Newton crib mattress we’ve had.

Naturepedic NEVER uses the materials below in any of their mattresses.

Flame retardants

Every Naturepedic mattress meets all government flammability requirements without any flame-retardant chemicals or barriers. They eliminate all highly flammable synthetics like polyurethane foam. Most off-gassing odors come from synthetic foams like polyurethane foam.

Glues and Adhesives 

Most mattresses have some form of glue, even the ones that call themselves “organic mattresses.” Naturepedic doesn’t use any glue at all. They have their own custom process to avoid adhesives or glues. There are concerns with glues and adhesives since they can be made of almost anything. It’s kind of like “fragrance” in beauty products. You never really know what’s in there since it’s used as a regulatory loophole.

Polyurethane Foam

I mentioned this a little above, but Polyurethane foam, including memory foam, can be found in almost all conventional mattresses. It’s mostly made of petroleum and other chemicals that are all highly flammable. Naturepedic does not use memory foam for this reason.

Naturepedic is also certified as Greenguard Gold certified by UL Environment and meets all of the Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS) standards and the Global Organic Latex Standard.

(Here’s a full list of mattress chemicals they recommend you avoid if you’re considering other brands.)

So, what is a Naturepedic mattress made of?

There are five materials in their mattresses:

  • Organic cotton fabric and fill
  • Organic wool batting
  • PLA layer– a high-performance fiber made from non-GMO sugarcane that adds resiliency and improved moisture-wicking
  • Organic latex–one of the most breathable and temperature-neutral materials available
  • Glueless encased coils

When we assembled our mattress, we could see EXACTLY what was inside it, and it was exactly as portrayed on their website.

Naturepedic Mattress layers: Review
what's inside Naturepedic Mattress

Here’s the encasement.

how to assemble Naturepedic Mattress

This picture shows the coils, which are customizable to your firmness preference. You can even choose different firmness since they’re two separate pieces, so if you like a soft mattress and your spouse likes a firm one, no problem. The two separate coil sections also help minimize motion transfer, meaning I don’t feel it when my husband moves in bed. And he moves a LOT in his sleep, so that’s critical for us.

Next comes the latex comfort layer. The organic latex comfort layer keeps you cool through the night by circulating heat and reducing hot spots that you might get from lying in one place on your current mattress. It also wicks any moisture.

For EOS Series mattresses (which we have), you can exchange the comfort layer for a different firmness for free within 90 days of the original purchase date. They recommend waiting 30 days since it takes time to adjust to any new mattress and the new feel and support. I should also note that the edges of the mattress have “edge support”, which helps the bed not sink in when you’re rolling out of it. This is especially important for anyone struggling to get in and out of bed. The plush-firmness option, however, may not feel quite as supportive for individuals who weigh over 230 lbs.

is Naturepedic worth it

Then, you zip all the layers up in the quilt.

Oh look, you just assembled your Naturepedic EOS mattress! Seriously! It took us about 10 minutes. The hardest part is when you get it about 3/4 of the way zipped since it gets TIGHT.

Naturepedic Organic Mattress Review

Our mattress arrived in 3 large boxes. They were heavy but not unmanageable. There were instructions on which box to open first. So once we started, it took no time. It was far more of a pain to move our other mattress (which was horrifically heavy) than it was to set this up.

online mattress order

Types of Naturepedic Mattresses

Naturepedic has 4 different mattress types, as well as a crib mattress.

1 and 2: Chorus and Serenade – great for kids

The Chorus and Serenade mattresses are their most basic mattresses, which works well for most sleepers. The queen collection starts at $1,999 for the Chorus mattress, and the Serenade mattress starts at $2,499. The Chorus mattress has a shorter profile and medium firmness comfort versus the Serenade, which has a higher profile and medium or firm comfort.

3: EOS – my pick for adults

The EOS Organic Latex Mattress collection has three options: the ClassicPillowtop, and Trilux. The Classic starts at $2,999, and the Pillowtop and Trilux start at $3,499.

The Classic and the Pillowtop both have encased coils, and the Classic is the lower profile of the two. The EOS Trilux is the lowest profile and has no coils. The Classic and Pillowtop have zippers to switch out layers and get the most durability out of your mattress.

We prefer a higher bed, so we purchased the EOS Classic for our home and purchased the EOS Pillowtop for our mountain house. However, we ended up exchanging the Pillowtop for the Classic since we didn’t like the Pillowtop as much.

4: Halcyon

The most luxurious option, in terms of materials and craftsmanship, is the Halcyon collection. There are 3 mattresses in the collection: Azure, Arcadia, and Elysium. The Azure has a 10″ profile, Arcadia has a 13″ and Elysium has a “16.

Crib Mattresses

Naturepedic also has crib mattresses, which I almost bought for my second baby, but I decided to stick to a Newton crib mattress since I really like the breathability feature they offer at the lower price point. But, I do think Naturepedic is probably safer, in terms if materials (i.e. non-toxic), so I almost feel guilty for not buying it for my kiddos now that I’m typing this out. I had the Newton with my first baby and just wanted to simplify things.

Naturepedic Pillows

I purchased the 2-in-1 pillows when I bought our second mattress, but we did not like them. It was hard to make the firmness exactly what I wanted, and it made a mess, especially when adding and removing the foam. Instead, I recommend Lagoon Pillows. I have the Fox, but Chinchilla is good if you like a softer option. The photos below show how messy the Naturepedic pillows can be.

Pros & Cons

Pros:

  • Comfortable
  • Non-toxic
  • American made
  • Good customer service to make tweaks
  • Variety of options (pillow top, price point, etc.)
  • Customizable to two sleepers

Cons:

  • VERY heavy once it’s put together. It’s can be hard to lift it to tuck in the bedsheets, but light mattresses generally aren’t comfortable.
  • Slightly more expensive than other high-quality mattresses on the market (but it’s worth it to me when I consider the long-term benefits)

FAQs

How long has Naturepedic been around?

Naturepedic started in 2003 and quickly became a leader in organic mattresses.

The founder, Barry Cik, founded Naturepedic after searching for a mattress for his grandson. Barry is an environmental engineer, and his background has led him to be very concerned about the harmful chemicals in conventional mattresses (and even some organic mattresses). So, when he couldn’t find a mattress for his grandson that he was comfortable with, he he set out to make one.

Now, Naturepedic Mattresses leads the industry by making the best organic mattresses designed for kids as well as luxury organic mattresses for adults. You can read more about Barry’s mission here. It’s still a family-owned business known for the best certified organic mattresses and great customer service.

Where are Naturepedic Mattresses made?

Each of these hybrid mattresses use a combination of domestic and imported fabric and components to make their mattresses. Many of their workers are skilled Amish craftspeople who take immense pride in their work, paying special attention to every detail. So, when you buy a Naturepedic mattress, you are supporting U.S. jobs and industry. And, you know that your bed was made by people who care.

How much is a Naturepedic Mattress?

Naturepedic has three adult mattress collections at different price points. They range from $2,000 to $10,000. The price depends on which one you get – sizing, materials, etc. All of the collections come in sizes from twin and twin XL, to king and even California king!

Why is Naturepedic so expensive?

Naturepedic uses organic cotton, latex, and wool, and these materials cost more than non-organic, which is not surprising. Organic cotton actually only makes up a little more than 1% of all cotton, so there’s little supply and high demand, making it more expensive.

Naturepedic also only uses third-party certified organic cotton, latex, or wool and they never blend it with non-organic. The mattresses are all certified organic and non-toxic. They’re also manufactured entirely in the United States, which I love.

Naturepedic Returns

On top of the high quality, they have a GREAT return policy, just in case you aren’t happy. They have a 30-day money-back guarantee on all baby and kids products and a 90-day money-back guarantee on adult mattresses. Note that these policies apply only to purchases made directly at naturepedic.com or by calling 1-800-917-3342, so I think it’s worth buying directly from them vs. a third-party retailer. (Companies like Amazon and Pottery Barn carry Naturepedic mattresses.) If you purchase from Naturepedic and use code TERI15 for 15% off, you’ll get free shipping and the return policy will still apply.

For the second mattress we ordered, we did not like the Pillowtop mattress as much as the Classic EOS. (The EOS is generally better for stomach and back sleepers due to the firmness.) So, I called their customer service number, and a REAL HUMAN picked up on the first ring and transferred me to the returns department. She helped me exchange the encasement, refunded me the difference, and sent it out – I was only on the phone for 7 minutes. Valerie, the customer service rep, was incredibly kind, helpful and efficient. That experience further solidified that I’ll never buy a mattress from anyone else again. Naturepedic for life!!

How to Assemble a Naturepedic Mattress

Here’s a video showing how we put ours together!

Bottom line: Are Naturepedic mattresses worth it?

100%. I didn’t realize just how poorly I slept until we got our Naturepedic. I used to wake up multiple times a night, and I blamed it on being a poor sleeper, or needing to use the restroom, or getting hot, etc. But it all stopped when we got our new mattress. Now, I fall asleep quickly and the middle of the night wakings have stopped. When I wake up in the morning, I am still surprised that I slept through the whole night, and I feel noticeably more well-rested.

My husband and I both had persistent back pain for a couple years with our old mattress, which we blamed on getting older, needing to see a chiropractor, needing to stretch more, holding a baby so much, etc. And yes, there is truth to all of that, but we can tell our backs don’t hurt as often since we got our Naturpedic mattress. The first time I laid on our new mattress, my body felt different. Things felt almost tingly, like our backs were able to actually rest without constantly working to try to support us in a crappy mattress. It was odd but awesome.

Another reason we love this mattress is that you can choose two different firmness options for each bed. We both wanted the Extra-Firm, but you can choose from five options and get different ones for each side of the bed: Plush (a 4 on the 10-point firmness scale), Medium (5), Cushion-Firm (6, and best for side sleepers), Firm (7), and Extra-Firm (8). The Firm and Extra-Firm options are best for stomach sleepers because they offer more support.

All of their mattresses have a 20-year limited warranty too. For the first 10 years, Naturepedic will repair or replace necessary items free of charge. Then during year 11, Naturepedic offers repairs/replacement credits that are equal to 50% off the component price, which goes down by 5% for the following 9 years. Knowing that I have a good warranty makes a huge difference when I decide to make a large purchase.

In short, we love, love, love our Naturepedic mattress.

We even bought a second mattress two weeks after we got our first one, to go in our home in Boone, and then we bought a third mattress a couple years later to go in our guest room in our new house.

Naturepedic has a 30-day money-back guarantee on all baby and kids products and a 90-day money-back guarantee on adult mattresses with 30 days on adult accessories.

I hope this post was helpful! If you have questions, let me know!

Shop the Post

terilyn signatureterilyn signature

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    16 responses to “Naturepedic Mattress Review (NOT-sponsored)”

    1. What was the combination of firmness for the coils and latex on the pillow top that you returned that was too soft? What is the combo on the classic that you are keeping?

    2. So the pillow top was too soft? I got it and I feel like it’s not soft enough! But I was debating going down to the Eos
      Classic and getting the wool water. We want soft and just to melt into the bed. What would you do if you had wanted super soft??

      • Ah, funny! Yes, I found it far too soft but I prefer a firm mattress. I’d suggest you call them and ask what they’d recommend! They have great customer service!

    3. We purchased the EOS Classic. I exchanged the comfort layer once so far. I started with the plush latex, but it was too stiff for a side sleeper. I was recommended to try the soft micro coil comfort layer. It’s softer than the latex , but I still find it very uncomfortable. I’m debating about upgrading to a pillow top, but I’m afraid to spend the extra money and still be unhappy. At this point, I have not slept well and regret my purchase. Do you have any suggestions?

    4. Thanks for the review! I’m looking into this mattress brand and see that they say their latex is GOLS or FSC certified latex. I am curious what you think about that? FSC is not an organic certification, so it seems that maybe not all of their latex is certified organic. Thoughts?

    5. Hi there! We are thinking about this mattress and wondering how it’s held up over time. We have a Purple brand mattress and after 3 years the special purple grid top layer has softened a lot and is no longer uncomfortable. So I am worried about how these non-traditional mattress companies quality holds up over time (as compared to big box like Tempurpedic, understanding it’s comparing apples to oranges since they don’t use organic materials).

      Thanks in advance!

    6. I purchased a classic king mattress on October 17, 2023. On December 8 asked for a layer swap for the top layer with the mini coils. Ever since then I have been calling them and emailing them on December 19, January 10, January 20, January 23, January 25 And January 29, and each time a person tells me that they have process my layer swap and I should be getting a confirmation soon. Now it is past the 90 days and I still cannot even get a live representative on the phone. The layer swap program is obviously a scam. Any suggestions on what I can do?

      • Strange! I did a layer swap and didn’t have that issue. I’d call them back and stay on the phone under the confirmation comes! 🙂

    7. How do you like your mattress today? Do you still prefer the extra firm layer? I want something I don’t sink or dip into and would be safe for a baby.

      • I absolutely LOVE my mattresses. We’ve purchased three total now and don’t regret a thing! We didn’t like the pillow top since we prefer a firmer mattress.

    8. Hi Terilyn,

      Thank you for your post about Naturepedic. I am considering the EOS Classic, do some side sleeping, but prefer a firmer mattress. Could you please share your exact configuration?

    9. One more question. I am also a little concerned that 3″ of latex on top feels a little jiggly when you first get on / in the bed. Do you find that to be an issue?

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.